← Social media bots, 2016–2026

How the definition of bots changed

Five rereadings of the same word, traced through the review's 3,233 included papers — from "automated identity shaping discourse" in 2016 to "is this even still the right word for an LLM agent" in 2026.

3,233 included papers, 2016–2026·← corpus overview·governance story →

Definitional drift, era by era

The single highest-cited paper from each window — the definition moved with whatever got attention.

2016–17The influence-botAutomated identity shaping discourse. The Rise of Social Bots, Comm. ACM.
2018–19The propaganda nodeA distribution mechanism, not an author. Low-credibility content, Nat. Comms.
2020–21The detection targetWhatever scores above threshold. Blame the Bot, J. Marketing (HCI split begins).
2022–23The collisionChatGPT arrives. Physician vs. AI Chatbot, JAMA — "bot" now means two things at once.
2024–26The LLM agentIs "bot" still the word? GenAI against humanity, J. Comp. Soc. Sci.

Which framings grew, which faded

Bot-persona tags by yeartop 6 of 16 categories
Loading…

What bots get linked to, over time

Term co-occurrence with "bot," by yeartop 7 terms

The dominant authors

Governance/legal setcomplete, n=111
Main corpuspartial fetch
Main-corpus ranking is seed-biased (snowball seeded from Ng & Carley's own taxonomy papers). The governance-set ranking — Gorwa, Howard & Kollanyi, Calo — is a cleaner read on cited authority.

Competing camps, not one line of research

Detection / network scienceStructural definition (graph position, Botometer score).IEEE Access · arXiv · Zenodo
Computational propagandaFunctional definition — what bots do to discourse.AAAI ICWSM · Social Media+Society
HCI / conversational agentDisclosed, usually benign dialogue system.ACM CHI · J. Marketing · JAMA
Persona co-occurrence, same paperbubble = # papers tagging both

Major journals and conferences

Top venues by included-paper count